Author Shirley Jackson ("The Lottery"; The Haunting of Hill House; We Have Always Lived in the Castle) casts a long and chilling shadow. The psychological thriller Shirley, from Susan Scarf Merrell (A Member of the Family), follows in its namesake's tradition.
Jackson and her husband, literary critic Stanley Edgar Hyman, lived in small-town Vermont while she wrote and he taught at Bennington College in the 1960s. In this book, Fred and Rose Nemser, Merrell's inventions, are newlyweds and move into the Hyman-Jackson home when Fred becomes a graduate student and teaching assistant. Rose, our 19-year-old narrator, is pregnant, recently rescued from a childhood of poverty and family dysfunction by her new husband; she is staggered by Shirley's big house, big family and art. Stan takes Fred under his wing, tutoring him in both their profession and in marriage. Shirley's mentorship of the malleable Rose is more complex.
Rose wants to write about Shirley; she wants to replace Shirley's children in their mother's heart; she wants to be Shirley. In her devotion, she can't help wondering about the phone calls that go unanswered every night, and the female student who went missing so many years ago (whom Shirley and Stan so emphatically did not know). Naturally, not all of Rose's overtures are welcome.
An apt tribute to Shirley Jackson herself, Merrell's novel recalls Daphne du Maurier's Rebecca and Edgar Allan Poe. Jackson's fans are the clear winners here; Shirley, Stan, Fred and Rose may not be so lucky. --Julia Jenkins, librarian and blogger at pagesofjulia