Notes: Google Settlement Criticized; Agency Model for Hachette
The Justice Department dealt a blow to the Google settlement in a filing Thursday that could influence a federal judge’s ruling later this month. Although the department "did not explicitly urge the court to reject the deal" and conceded the new agreement was an improvement over the previous version, "it said the changes were not enough to placate concerns that the deal would grant Google a monopoly over millions of orphan works," the New York Times reported.
In addition, the department called the revised agreement still unsatisfactory regarding authors’ copyrights, too broad in scope and said it '"suffers from the same core problem as the original agreement: it is an attempt to use the class-action mechanism to implement forward-looking business arrangements that go far beyond the dispute before the court in this litigation." The parties were encouraged to continue their discussions. A hearing on the agreement is scheduled for February 18 with Judge Denny Chin of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York.
---
David Young, Hachette Book Group USA's CEO, sent an e-mail to agents Thursday announcing the company's decision to "transition to selling our e-books through an agency model," giving Macmillan an ally in its confrontation with Amazon. GalleyCat posted a copy of the letter.
Young wrote that the agency model "allows Hachette to make pricing decisions that are rational and reflect the value of our authors' works. In the long run this will enable Hachette to continue to invest in and nurture authors' careers--from major blockbusters to new voices. Without this investment in our authors, the diversity of books available to consumers will contract, as will the diversity of retailers, and our literary culture will suffer."
He also noted that Hachette intends "to release HBG e-books simultaneously with the hardcover (or first format print edition)."
---
Macmillan's CEO John Sargent praised bricks-and-mortar retailers in a new message to authors and illustrators that was posted Thursday on the publisher's website.
In addition to explaining Macmillan's position on digital book royalties, Sargent noted that many people "are wondering what has taken so long for Amazon and Macmillan to reach a conclusion. I want to assure you that Amazon has been working very, very hard and always in good faith to find a way forward with us. Though we do not always agree, I remain full of admiration and respect for them. Both of us look forward to being back in business as usual."
He also offered "a salute to the bricks and mortar retailers who sell your books in their stores and on their related websites. Their support for you, and us, has been remarkable over the last week. From large chains to small independents, they committed to working harder than ever to help your books find your readers."
In conclusion, Sargent said that he "cannot tell you when we will resume business as usual with Amazon, and needless to say I can promise nothing on the buy buttons. You can tell by the tone of this letter though that I feel the time is getting near to hand."
---
Macmillan ran a full-page advertisement in New York Times Wednesday for Atul Gawande's The Checklist Manifesto: How to Get Things Right that included the line: "Available at booksellers everywhere except Amazon."
---
Is niche the future of publishing? Digital Book World examined the business models of publishers Harlequin, Hay House, Osprey and Chelsea Green and concluded "these publishers show that being a hyper-targeted brand is incredibly powerful. And you can't really argue with the results."
"We had to become niche or else we wouldn’t have survived," said Margo Baldwin, co-founder, president and publisher of Chelsea Green. "To try to be a generalist as a small publisher is basically suicide."
---
Now that several days have passed since Amazon "more or less 'de-friended'" Macmillan, the Guardian's Scott Westerfeld wrote that "some have likened this de-listing as a 'shock and awe' campaign, a stunning display of muscle power from an industry leader (or proto-monopoly). But I think it's a bit more pathetic than that. It reminds me more of an educational film from an old Simpsons episode, the one with the tagline, 'Sorry, Jimmy, but you said you wanted to live in a world without zinc!' "
---
Lisa Somerville and Valerie Kirkland plan to open Apostrophe Books in its new Long Beach, Calif., location sometime around St. Patrick's Day. In her column on Gazettes.com, Wendy Hornsby celebrated the imminent opening by observing that she intends "to celebrate St. Patrick’s Day by shopping for a new book."
---
Gottwals Books, which has used bookstores in Warner Robins and Byron, Ga., will open another shop in Macon this weekend. Co-owner Shane Gottwals told 13WMAZ that "we were looking for a kind of opportunity that really only came because of the recession; with rent rates and different opportunities that come up with a recession, we were able to fit into this Northside Drive location really well."
He added that "the goal for us is to be in an area where people are reading, and this is really--besides a couple other places--it's really a part of Macon that needs a used bookstore, so we just felt like it was a really good fit."
---
Seattle's used bookstores "are confident they have a secure place in the community" despite the advent of e-reading devices, the Spectator reported
"One of the reasons you go into shops is so that you can get ideas about things you didn't know about," said Kris Minta, owner of Spine and Crown. "You can't do that very well online. That's the place of the shop, and that is the duty of a used bookstore owner: to present this panoply of ideas in an attempt to inspire people.
"There are thousands of life-changing doors in my shop and people could walk out with one of those doors," Minta added. "If you aren't always discovering, what is life worth living for? My shop is to make that philosophy concrete."
---
Robert Warren, owner of Skyline Books--a used book mainstay in New York City for two decades--"bid the neighborhood farewell" last Saturday as his shop held a going out of business sale. Warren told the Daily News he couldn't afford to renew his lease, which had increased 50%, nor could he compete in a changing book trade.
"The evils are three," he said: "The big book chains, Amazon.com and online auctions like eBay."
---
Prime Crime Mystery Bookstore, Ottawa, will close March 13. Quill & Quire reported that owner Linda Wiken "told the Ottawa Citizen she had been trying to sell the store for over a year, and that it was 'just time to move on.'" Prime Crime won the 2001 Canadian Booksellers Association award as specialty bookseller of the year.
---
USA Today paid a visit to the home of children's writer and illustrator Jerry Pinkney, who recently won the Caldecott Medal for The Lion & the Mouse. Calling himself "a storyteller at heart" he said he asks himself, "Will I, in the process of making pictures, learn something new?"
---
Calling their list an "ideas factory for birthday, Christmas, Hanukkah for years to come" for the political junkies on your gift list, Washington Post's the Fix featured a list of favorite political fiction and nonfiction titles recommended by the "Fixistas." The top vote-getter for fiction was The Last Hurrah by Edwin O'Connor, while Robert Caro's The Power Broker topped the nonfiction list.