Five more parents have joined the lawsuit filed in federal district court in May by PEN America, Penguin Random House, authors, and parents of students in Escambia County, Fla., against the county school district and school board over book bannings and the restriction of access to the area's public school libraries.
Plaintiffs noted that since the lawsuit was filed, the school district has "continued its policies of removing books from school libraries. In that time an additional 21 book titles have been challenged and 17 have been restricted, including Pulitzer Prize-winning Middlesex by Jeffrey Eugenides, the landmark graphic novel Watchmen by Alan Moore, and the horror novel It by Stephen King."
Carin Smith, one of the parents who joined the suit, said, "As a Black mother of two teenage girls, I know how important it is for our children to have access to books like The Freedom Writers Diary and Beloved. I respect the right of parents to make decisions with and for their own children. In my opinion, we should not shy away from the real, raw struggles this country has faced, and my girls shouldn't be deprived access to books on those issues because our stories make someone else uncomfortable."
And Benjamin Glass, another parent joining the suit, said, "Someone with a master's degree in library science, also known as a librarian, should be deciding what's in libraries--not politicians. Parents, of course, should be involved in what is in their own child's best interest to read. But they shouldn't be making decisions on behalf of other people's children. You parent your child, I'll parent mine, and we'll let librarians do their jobs. That sounds good to me."
---
|
Sally Bradshaw |
In a Tampa Bay Times column called "What my second grade 'honorable mention' taught me about Florida book bans," Sally Bradshaw, founder and owner of Midtown Reader, Tallahassee, Fla., recalls winning "a box of beautiful hardback books" for her honorable mention in an essay-writing contest, books that she enjoyed starting on the ride home.
"As a bookworm growing up in a small Southern town, books were my portal to worlds very different from my own," she continues. "Our public library was a sanctuary. Our local bookstore, a hidden gem. I couldn't wait to get lost in the stacks by myself--away from my mom for just long enough to imagine I was a grown up with the power to choose my own adventure.
"I loved the sound of the librarian's stamp in a book's jacket pocket. I rushed to volunteer when I was old enough at my own school library. It was among those bookshelves that I found the power to see into a world beyond my own experience; to understand the far-ranging thoughts of others; and to find comfort in the knowledge that people can become extraordinary despite the trauma and challenges they endure.
"Never did I imagine that other children would not have the power and solace afforded by an unfettered access to books. Yet, today this is the stark new reality in Florida and increasingly across America. We have arrived at the Orwellian moment when under the ironic cry of 'freedom,' Florida government has effectively empowered extremist groups and outliers to become censors for everyone, pulling literature from public bookshelves if just one parent finds a book offensive. More than 350 books have been removed from school shelves in Florida over the last year.
"In Florida's Panhandle this has a particularly devastating effect, because rampant poverty in our region makes libraries the only available source of books for many thousands of children. Absent stories and the power of the written word, and without books in libraries which make those stories available to all, how will we give these children the tools to understand and overcome their own circumstances and provide a vision to which they can aspire?"
She concludes, "Recently someone asked why our bookstore Midtown Reader in Tallahassee has made banned books a regular topic of discussion. We've worked hard to be a place where everyone, of every background and political persuasion can gather to read, think and share. We've refrained from partisan battles preferring to provide diverse content and allow readers to pursue ideas and consider opposing viewpoints as a healthy and appropriate outcome of reading and learning.
"But when it comes to real freedom--the kind where you exercise the sovereignty of the individual while others are fully allowed to do the same--there can be no compromise."
---
|
Lee Rowland |
Lee Rowland, policy director at the New York Civil Liberties Union, will become executive director of the National Coalition Against Censorship, effective September 11. She replaces Chris Finan, who announced in March that he is retiring. Before joining NCAC in 2017, Finan was president of the American Booksellers Foundation for Free Expression, which he joined in 1998. (ABFFE merged with the ABA in 2015 and became the American Booksellers for Free Expression.) Earlier he was executive director of the Media Coalition.
Rowland served for more than a decade as a lawyer for the American Civil Liberties Union, the Brennan Center for Justice, and the New York Civil Liberties Union. She has extensive experience as a litigator, lobbyist, and public speaker. She has served as lead counsel in federal First Amendment cases involving public employee speech rights, the First Amendment rights of community advocates, government regulation of digital speech, and state secrecy surrounding the lethal injection process. She has also written many amicus briefs and blogs, about issues such as speech and privacy, student and public employee speech, obscenity, and the Communications Decency Act. She also has represented several NCAC partner organizations.
NCAC chair Emily Knox called Rowland "an experienced and talented defender of free expression. Her decades of work as a civil libertarian make her the right person to lead NCAC as it confronts the book banning crisis and the many other difficult challenges to free expression."
Rowland said, "As a lifelong free speech advocate, I am thrilled to join the NCAC, an organization I have long respected for its principled and nonpartisan commitment to free expression. Our rights to read, think, create, and explore are always essential to a just, egalitarian, and inclusive democracy. NCAC is uniquely positioned to help us defend those rights against censorship and oppression. It's an honor to be joining the organization in this fight."
---
|
Dave Grogan |
American Booksellers for Free Expression director Dave Grogan has rejoined the board of the Media Coalition, as reported in Bookselling This Week. The Media Coalition is "an association that protects the First Amendment rights of producers and distributors of books, movies, magazines, recordings, home video, and video games, and defends the American public's First Amendment right to have access to the broadest possible range of information, opinion and entertainment."