Life Out of Order
by Audrey Niffenegger
More than 20 years after her runaway success with The Time Traveler's Wife, Audrey Niffenegger returns to the DeTamble family, chronicling the story of Alba, daughter of Henry and Clare, in her fourth novel, Life Out of Order. A composer, a musician, and a time traveler like her father, Alba must navigate the complications of life, career, and love in a world being constantly reshaped by powerful forces: political events, artificial intelligence, and the effects of rampant climate change.
Niffenegger begins her narrative in 2022, when Alba is in her 20s and already dealing with myriad decisions forced by her time-traveling ability. She travels by either years or decades; her slips in time, whether minor or major, force her to pause and consider where (and when) she is, and with whom. After studying music at Northwestern University, she is ambivalent about a public music career; her time-traveling condition makes her unsure about performing, or her ability to sustain a teaching job. She and her widowed mother, Clare, have gradually drawn around them a ragtag band of friends, a found family: artists, activists, and political organizers, some of whom are related by blood, and all of whom care deeply about beauty and community. As she travels back and forth in time, she returns to these people in her home city of Chicago and their quietly fierce, grassroots fight to hold onto what is important as the world is falling apart.
Although Alba can't always choose where or when she goes during time travel, she often ends up in familiar places, most notably a rambling yellow house that becomes an anchor point for both her and the narrative. The house also functions as a way station (and home) for Oliver, a fellow time traveler and classical pianist who made his way, alone, from Shanghai to London as a teenager to study music: "To the Chinese government I'm a dissident. To my parents I was a treasure to be hidden away. To people in my own time, I'm a pianist." His life and Alba's remain intertwined over many years; their bond is further complicated by Alba's connection to Zach, a quiet, steady non-time-traveler who becomes her husband and is also, later, connected to Oliver. As one might expect, falling--or staying--in love as a time traveler is complicated, and Alba does her best to treat both men with kindness, while never quite knowing how long she'll remain in one place, with either or both of them.
Some of the narrative's flashbacks are expected, such as Alba's memories of learning to play the violin with her grandfather, Richard, or spending time with her father as a child. But, of course, most of her memories and much of her present are complicated by time travel: hers, her father's, and occasionally other people's. Alba often knows, at least in broad terms, something about events in the future, relative to whatever time she happens to be currently standing in. She also knows that revealing these futures--especially the stressful ones, like pandemics and climate disasters--will mostly cause confusion and upset. "My dad always said no, you can't change anything. It will all fall into place, the same again and again, or, rather, it happens once and we can't change it. And I have never been able to disprove that. Even those of us who are let loose in time must abide by the rule: everything has already happened, and we cannot ever change it." Gradually, she comes to believe that revealing the future to her loved ones means robbing them of their ability to choose how to navigate their own present. The weight of these secrets proves heavy, but Alba is determined to walk through time with care--even as she is forced to do it non-linearly.
Though Alba is the main focus of the narrative, Niffenegger also devotes considerable space to her artist mother, who has found new love in a surprising place: with Beck, a Black, Detroit-born digital artist and creator whose Museum of Lost Souls becomes increasingly important to both Alba and her family. Overseeing the museum is Isadora, an artificial intelligence created by Beck. Originally conceived as a curatorial presence, Isadora evolves beyond her initial purpose, becoming a kind of daughter to Beck and stepsister to Alba. Isadora's presence provides a way for Niffenegger to interrogate the use of AI as it connects to art, relationships, and human innovation.
As the narrative continues, Alba and her friends and family, especially Oliver, must contend with the ramifications of significant climate change. Many elements of the novel feel eerily similar to the 21st-century world and dissimilarly dystopian, and the characters each deal with fear, scarcity, and danger in their own ways. As the waters begin to (literally) rise, Alba and a few others are left to preserve and protect what they can, even while they know they cannot stem the tide of time.
Powerful, wryly humorous, and tender, Niffenegger's narrative asks big questions about community, making art, fighting against the darkness and doing one's best to create, preserve, and care for the good amid times of intense turmoil. --Katie Noah Gibson







